Thursday, August 25, 2022
HomeEducationTennessee delays giving faculties A-F letter grades — once more

Tennessee delays giving faculties A-F letter grades — once more

For a fifth straight yr, Tennessee has delayed its plan to begin giving A-F grades to its 1,800-plus public faculties.

Training Commissioner Penny Schwinn notified district leaders Wednesday about her resolution for an additional pause, which she blamed on inconsistency in knowledge brought on by three straight years of pandemic-related disruptions throughout the state.

Particularly, Schwinn cited uneven participation charges of scholars taking state checks underneath the Tennessee Complete Evaluation Program, often called TCAP. The state depends on these take a look at outcomes over a number of years when evaluating lecturers and scholar progress and score the effectiveness of colleges and districts.

The commissioner stated virtually a fourth of colleges didn’t meet the Tennessee and nationwide normal of 95% of their college students collaborating in state testing within the 2020-21 college yr.

One other delay in letter grades means Tennessee mother and father and communities received’t have as a lot simple details about the standard of their faculties as supposed underneath a 2016 state legislation ordering the creation of a brand new grading system.

The state had deliberate to start assigning grades in 2018 however has repeatedly pushed pause. First, on-line testing issues known as into query the reliability of 2018 scores and led to emergency laws in order that faculties wouldn’t be punished for poor outcomes. Then in 2020, the pandemic prompted the cancellation of state testing nationwide

In 2021, the state used outcomes from its first pandemic take a look at scores, which confirmed a dramatic reversal of earlier beneficial properties in achievement, to develop studying enchancment plans as a substitute of to price faculties or consider lecturers. That yr, the state reported a higher-than-expected testing participation price, regardless of administering TCAPs throughout the pandemic.

However now, after this yr’s scores confirmed a return to pre-COVID ranges, Schwinn is suggesting that inconsistent participation knowledge throughout a number of years is skewing the outcomes for holding faculties accountable.

Tennessee deliberate to base its general college letter grades on scholar take a look at outcomes over a number of years, in addition to different elements corresponding to persistent absenteeism, out-of-school suspensions, and the readiness of highschool graduates for faculty and profession.

In her letter to superintendents, Schwinn stated, “it isn’t attainable to subject letter grades that pretty and transparently talk the efficiency and progress of colleges right now.”

“This A-F letter grading accountability system ought to at all times mirror constant and reliable data to households, and particularly so on this inaugural yr,” she wrote.

Schwinn stated the state “stays dedicated to accountability” and nonetheless plans to subject its lists of high-growth and low-performing faculties, together with these which are academically within the state’s backside 5%. The general public launch is scheduled for Sept. 12.

“We’ll proceed to have fun our high-progress and high-performing faculties,” she stated, “in addition to supporting and intervening in our low-performing faculties.”

Leaders of a number of training advocacy teams say they’re anxious to see that knowledge.

Gini Pupo-Walker, state director of The Training Belief in Tennessee, says she has extra questions than solutions primarily based on Schwinn’s letter to district leaders.

“How can we now have confidence within the designation of low-performing faculties if we don’t have faith in how participation impacts the general metrics?” Pupo-Walker requested.

“It’s additionally necessary to assist stakeholders perceive why final yr’s participation price is affecting college accountability this yr,” she stated. “Finally, it’s necessary to understand how our college students and faculties are doing, and for us to see how they’re faring on a number of measures over time.”

Within the meantime, Tennessee’s fundamental platform for sharing details about its public faculties is falling in need of its objective to supply mother and father and communities with essential details about how faculties are assembly the wants of all college students.

Since late spring, the state’s on-line report card has been unavailable, making it tougher for fogeys making an attempt to search for 2020-21 state testing knowledge, in addition to different details about college attendance, staffing, and funds. 

Schwinn advised superintendents the state will publish the report card with up to date knowledge in late November.

You’ll be able to learn Schwinn’s letter to superintendents on the backside of this web page.

Marta W. Aldrich is a senior correspondent and covers the statehouse for Chalkbeat Tennessee. Contact her at



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments